Omg man so pleased you’re back! Your book was one of a few that got me back into reading wholesale, and I really, really love everything you write here. Thanks for continuing to share your thoughts.
I am not as much of a doomer as others when it comes to AI. It seems me that Silicon Valley has essentially created an alternate lifeform with an alternate mode of thinking. "Labor gives meaning" never made sense to me. No one likes to work. I guess it's because my job isn't that important (I'm a paralegal) I also want to make a distinction between labor for income and creative income. Why does it matter to me that AGI can write or do my job better than me? I still like to write creatively. People still play sports even though they'll never be the "best" at it. It doesn't really matter to me. Maybe I'm being naive.
How others feel about this also important. And how can AI even interface with the real world when it has no body? I am a little ignorant on robotics so maybe I'm wrong. Anyway, all of this is still up on the air. Once mass unemployment occurs, then we'll start getting answers. Whatever happens, history will keep going. That's what matters to me the most.
Thanks for this review! It made me feel a lot more interested in the book, and in Gasda's work in general.
Re: the AI prognostications, here's where I'm at after a few years of serious study and job interviews with AI firms yada yada. We'll start here: my wife is a general contractor. She builds and remodels houses. Beyond the nowhere-near solved problem of economically and materially efficient general purpose robotics (particularly w/r/t the cheap and abundant labor provided by a steady stream of ambitious immigrants), an LLM or agent swarm is laughably incapable of doing my wife's job. Shit moves too quickly, people change their mind too much, a human touch is actually needed in relations with subcontractors, on-the-fly aesthetic decision-making, talking clients off the ledge, reading between the lines, etc. etc. And I work at a college where people get together and talk about books. Agent swarms might be able to replace a handful of jobs in the short term, but ~90% of these jobs aren't going anywhere.
I think AI is disastrous for those whose jobs are primarily reading and responding to digital communications and organizing digital data—but with respect to the waking and working life of most Americans, those jobs are already practically invisible. I passed through my eschatological phase about this shit when I realized how much of my reality is neither defined nor animated by people who, to quote Kendrick, live their lives on the computer.
“Here’s the fact of the matter: the year is 2026 and the art we make in the next 5-10 years might be the last meaningful art that can be made before machine intelligence maps the neural territory required to create aesthetic superstimulus…” Not sure “fact of the matter” is how I would preface the hypothetical scenario you follow it with. But that aside—what “meaningful art” has to do with “aesthetic superstimulus” I have no idea. Meaning and aesthetic stimulus are not particularly linked.
Omg man so pleased you’re back! Your book was one of a few that got me back into reading wholesale, and I really, really love everything you write here. Thanks for continuing to share your thoughts.
You are cooking
I am not as much of a doomer as others when it comes to AI. It seems me that Silicon Valley has essentially created an alternate lifeform with an alternate mode of thinking. "Labor gives meaning" never made sense to me. No one likes to work. I guess it's because my job isn't that important (I'm a paralegal) I also want to make a distinction between labor for income and creative income. Why does it matter to me that AGI can write or do my job better than me? I still like to write creatively. People still play sports even though they'll never be the "best" at it. It doesn't really matter to me. Maybe I'm being naive.
How others feel about this also important. And how can AI even interface with the real world when it has no body? I am a little ignorant on robotics so maybe I'm wrong. Anyway, all of this is still up on the air. Once mass unemployment occurs, then we'll start getting answers. Whatever happens, history will keep going. That's what matters to me the most.
Thanks for this review! It made me feel a lot more interested in the book, and in Gasda's work in general.
Re: the AI prognostications, here's where I'm at after a few years of serious study and job interviews with AI firms yada yada. We'll start here: my wife is a general contractor. She builds and remodels houses. Beyond the nowhere-near solved problem of economically and materially efficient general purpose robotics (particularly w/r/t the cheap and abundant labor provided by a steady stream of ambitious immigrants), an LLM or agent swarm is laughably incapable of doing my wife's job. Shit moves too quickly, people change their mind too much, a human touch is actually needed in relations with subcontractors, on-the-fly aesthetic decision-making, talking clients off the ledge, reading between the lines, etc. etc. And I work at a college where people get together and talk about books. Agent swarms might be able to replace a handful of jobs in the short term, but ~90% of these jobs aren't going anywhere.
I think AI is disastrous for those whose jobs are primarily reading and responding to digital communications and organizing digital data—but with respect to the waking and working life of most Americans, those jobs are already practically invisible. I passed through my eschatological phase about this shit when I realized how much of my reality is neither defined nor animated by people who, to quote Kendrick, live their lives on the computer.
“Here’s the fact of the matter: the year is 2026 and the art we make in the next 5-10 years might be the last meaningful art that can be made before machine intelligence maps the neural territory required to create aesthetic superstimulus…” Not sure “fact of the matter” is how I would preface the hypothetical scenario you follow it with. But that aside—what “meaningful art” has to do with “aesthetic superstimulus” I have no idea. Meaning and aesthetic stimulus are not particularly linked.